Monday, March 4, 2013

Post-"Harlem Shake" Appropriation Guilt

Two weeks ago, I did not know what the "Harlem Shake" was. If you were to ask me, I honestly still cannot tell you definitively because I lack the knowledge, understanding, and appreciation of the real Harlem Shake (please note the lack of scare quotes) that has its roots in Harlem's African-American community. I only know it from the meme craze that has been sweeping YouTube and, thus, my Facebook news feed. Today, I participated in a "Harlem Shake" event coordinated by our fabulous LLTC Student Senate.

I know why our Student Senate did coordinated our LLTC "Harlem Shake" event. The "Harlem Shake" events bring people together, get people to participate in something bigger than themselves here on campus, then (after the YouTube video gets uploaded) get people to share in something much bigger than themselves, something that feels global and universal.

However, what something feels and what something actually is can be two completely different things. TIME recently did a piece on cultural appropriation of the "Harlem Shake", sharing filmmaker Chris McGuire's interviews with Harlem citizens regarding their reactions to the "Harlem Shake" meme:
One of my personal heroes, Melissa Harris-Perry, addresses the cultural appropriation of the "Harlem Shake" meme in this video:
Food for thought, indeed.

This is a difficult subject for me, because I work with, for, and among people whose cultures have been and are being appropriated regularly by and in mainstream culture. One of the toughest lessons about cultural appropriation that, often, people (usually) outside of the appropriated culture do not understand or acknowledge the wrongness (for lack of a maybe-more appropriate term) of robbing (for lack of a better term) a culture of something powerful, meaningful, special and, then, of bastardizing (again, for lack of a better term) that special, meaningful, powerful cultural something for the outside culture's own use, amusement, and or gain.

The Harlem Shake is a notable cultural phenomenon. The "Harlem Shake" is a passing Internet fad. Is the "Harlem Shake" a cultural appropriation of the Harlem Shake? Before today, I assumed those two things were separate entities; I did not consider that the meme was an appropriation of the dance. However, now, after considering the weighty evidence and judging from the sinking feeling in the pit of my stomach, I think it is. Does the "Harlem Shake" accurately, respectfully, adequately represent or pay tribute to the Harlem Shake? No, absolutely not. That answer appears to be crystal clear. Can and has the "Harlem Shake" evolve into something else apart from the original Harlem Shake while still bearing its name? I don't know.

1 comment:

  1. All things considered, our "LLTC Shake" seemed to bring our campus community together in a meaningful, fun way: http://youtu.be/Cv2akLfdbr8

    I'm still torn on the appropriation aspect.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.